What happens when someone dies unexpectedly?

Read time will display here.

Summary

So far in this season, we've focused on what happens when someone dies at an old age or after living with longer-term illness. But what happens when someone dies unexpectedly?

From what paramedics do when they arrive on a scene when someone is very unwell or has died, to what an ICU is like and how the decision is made that a patient is no longer benefitting from treatment, in this episode we're learning about sudden and unexpected deaths.

Director of strategic wellbeing for Queensland Ambulance Service and former paramedic Todd, talks us through what happens when you call Triple Zero (000) when someone has died.

Then, Townsville University Hospital clinical nurse consultant Carly explains what kind of care is provided in an intensive care unit (ICU) and why not every patient can be saved. Her colleague, donation specialist nurse Meagan, shares why the conditions required for organ donation mean that donors have almost always died unexpectedly, and what conversations will be had with their family about their donation wishes.

What services need to attend if someone dies unexpectedly at home? Who leads conversations about whether life-sustaining treatment is in a person's best interest? Who gets to decide if you’ll become an organ donor?

Listen on to find out.

This episode is part of the podcast series It Can’t Hurt to Ask ... about Death and Dying.

Featured in the episode

Carly Evans

Carly

Carly is a clinical nurse consultant in the Intensive Care Unit at Townsville University Hospital. Having spent nearly 12 years working in Intensive Care, she is passionate about ensuring that North Queenslanders receive clinically excellent and compassionate care closer to home during some of the most challenging moments in people’s lives.

Lauren Sherritt

Lauren

With equal parts curiosity and caution, Lauren has delved into all things death and dying to produce and host this podcast series. She's talked to healthcare workers, allied health staff and people with lived experience from right across Queensland to get the full picture of what happens at the end of life and how we can prepare to live, and die, as well as we can.

Meagan Baldwin

Meagan

Meagan is a donation specialist nurse coordinator at Townsville University Hospital. She has worked in ICUs across Australia for 22 years, spending 14 of those in Townsville. She finds purpose in providing care for families during some of their toughest moments and loves working in a highly skilled multidisciplinary team of healthcare professionals serving their community.

Todd Wehr

Todd

Todd is a former paramedic and the Director of Strategic Wellbeing for Queensland Ambulance Service (QAS). In his role, he combines his passion for emergency healthcare and psychology to find ways to continue supporting the wellbeing of paramedics and QAS staff, to enable them to have long, fulfilling and healthy careers.

Episode resources

Care at the end of life is a campaign and resource hub for Queenslanders with information about advance care planning and support for patients, carers and families.

Talking about death and dying can bring up challenging emotions. If you or someone you know is struggling with their mental wellbeing, support is available:

  • Lifeline: call 13 11 14 (24 hours a day) if you are experiencing a personal crisis or chat to a counsellor online.
  • Beyond Blue: call 1300 224 636 for broad mental wellbeing support or speak to a counsellor online.
  • Griefline: call 1300 845 745 (9am–6pm, Monday - Friday, 12 noon–6pm weekends).
  • PalAssist has general information and advice about palliative care services in Queensland. Call 1800 772 273 (free for Queensland residents) or chat online (from 7am to 7pm, 7 days).
  • In an emergency, always call Triple Zero (000).

The following services were discussed in the episode or can provide additional information and resources:

Disclaimer

The stories and conversations shared by everyone in this podcast reflect their personal views, experiences and opinions. They are shared for informational and educational purposes only and are not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.

Queensland Health does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the views expressed by guests and accepts no responsibility for any loss or damage that may result from relying on this content.

If you have questions about your health or treatment, please speak with a qualified healthcare professional.

Transcript

Lauren (in interview)

Obviously your —the work you do is all focused around, saving lives really and, and  seeing people who've come in with a really acute situation and we're trying to  make sure, as you said, that person can, can go back home.

Lauren

I'm talking to Carly, a critical care nurse  from Townsville University Hospital. She works in the intensive care unit,  where, to put it simply, she saves lives.

Lauren (in interview)

So, it's a bit different to then be asking you  about what happens when that doesn't work.

Lauren

I'm in Brisbane, so we met online. As soon as  I started this interview, I realised there was something different about it.

Lauren (in interview)

But when someone is in that really kind of  acute situation, what are some of the reasons that medical intervention may  ultimately not work?

Lauren

Hi, my name's Lauren. If you've listened to  other episodes in this series, you'll know that it's all about getting used to  talking about death and dying.

From our health experts, I've learned that  these days the majority of us are going to die either at the end of a long life  or after a known illness. Talking about dying helps us plan ahead for that, and  there's a lot of useful planning to be done. But not everyone gets to know  their time is growing short and to really start thinking about the important  things.

For some, death is sudden and unexpected.  Accidents and injuries, sudden acute illnesses, or large cardiac or  neurological events can mean that an otherwise healthy seeming person might die  really quickly.

What I learned from making this episode is  that while it's easy to talk about death when it's slowly approaching, it might  never be easy to talk about the sudden deaths of people who were healthy or  young.

But that doesn't mean we shouldn't talk about  it, because there are ways we can plan ahead that might help, even in life's  most unplanned-for moments. Thinking ahead about these times can actually make  a really big difference.

I wanted to begin this episode from the start.  So, before we hear more from Carly in the ICU, I had a chat with Todd.

Todd

My name is Todd and I'm the Director of Strategic  Wellbeing for the Queensland Ambulance Service.

Lauren

If someone dies suddenly out of hospital or  gets so sick or injured that they could die, it's likely you would call an  ambulance, and the crew would often be the first people to arrive at the scene.

I asked Todd how paramedics manage these tough  scenarios.

Todd

It takes 3 years training to become a  paramedic in terms of a university degree. You get lots of opportunities to  learn a lot about different components around anatomy and physiology, but you  also get a lot of opportunity to practise what would happen in the real world  in terms of scenarios where they're really getting a chance to not only  understand the skills but practice those skills, and particularly in situations  where somebody has died where it might be somewhat more confronting.

Lauren

I’ve had to call an ambulance when someone was  really unwell. From the operator on the phone to the paramedics who came to my  house, I was surprised and then later intrigued by their behaviour. It didn't  match my own.

While I was heightened —it was an emergency —they were calm, full of questions,  deliberate. It was both reassuring and mildly frustrating.

I asked Todd to explain why paramedics are  trained to behave the way they do even when delivering potentially life-saving  emergency care.

Todd

There's a lot that paramedics do as they're  getting to the scene and as they're arriving on scene that I think people don't  necessarily recognise.

They're thinking about a whole range of  things, and when they're getting on scene, initially they're thinking about  safety. Is the scene safe both for them to go into, and is it safe for the  people that are around the scene?

So, they'll tend to be not necessarily quickly  jumping out of their ambulance when they get there. They might actually be  looking out the windscreen, checking out for safety and making sure  everything's okay. And that also gives them a bit of a view as to, are there  any people on scene that might need some additional support as well?

Lauren

So that difference I was feeling between my  surging adrenaline and the paramedic's calm, methodical manner wasn't all in my  head. It was deliberate and for good reason.

Did you know that in most situations,  emergency services personnel are actually trained not to run? I didn't, but  when Todd explained why, it made total sense

Todd

The first level of safety is for them, and if  they actually fall over and injure themselves, they can't help the patient or  anybody else on scene then, and then they become a patient.

So, you'll see them being really calm and  talking measured and they might even be asking questions of a bystander or a  person on scene. Which is really helping them to get the information around the  patient, but also helping the other people on scene to have a sense of control  and to be able to calm down as well.

Lauren

Todd told me that if there's a chance  someone's life could be saved, that's what paramedics will focus on. They do  what they can to stabilise the patient to the point that they can safely  transfer them to hospital.

This might involve calling for other  resources, like an ambulance that has a doctor or different equipment, and  liaising with their destination hospital, as well as talking to anyone on the  scene that could give them a picture of what's happened to the patient leading  up to the current event.

But sometimes it's clear a person's life won't  be saved. They have died. This can be hard for members of the public to accept  in the moment.

Todd

A paramedic might say pretty quickly that  there's nothing else that we can do. And it's usually based off what they're  seeing on the screen there and how long the person might have been dead.

Sometimes families can get a bit upset because  they think the paramedics are not doing anything. We see on movies and TV shows  where there's a flat line on the screen, but if you keep on working and keep  on, you know, defibrillating with that defibrillator, then that person will  eventually become okay.

The reality is, when somebody has that flat  line on the screen, there is no level of defibrillation that you can do, to  bring them back. Sometimes, there's nothing else clinically that you can do for  that patient.

Lauren

Todd explained to me that deciding when to  stop treatment is also part of caring for both the patient and those around  them.

Todd

Paramedics are usually pretty good at  explaining to bystanders what's happened from the best of what they can work  out, and why they might not be able to continue to resuscitate that person, so  that the family members or bystanders can understand that as much as possible.

Lauren

A paramedic's job extends beyond caring for  the initial patient, particularly when they've been called out for a fatality.  Todd explained that paramedics try to consider everyone on the scene when  someone has died.

Todd

It's not uncommon for somebody else on scene  to be emotionally distressed and need some additional support.

There is a whole range of emotions that people  who witness a serious incident or accident, or people who witness somebody die,  there's a whole range of emotions that they might have, and they're all  completely normal.

Sometimes they might even have chest pain from  cardiac issues that they might have and the stress causes them to have chest  pain. Then there's another patient for the paramedics to consider.

Lauren

Todd told me that there are other  misconceptions about what paramedics do or don't do, especially when someone  has died.

Todd

I think a bit like TV; it gets a bit skewed in  terms of what paramedics do. In Queensland, we don't transport dead bodies from  the scene. The undertaker or the mortuary would actually provide those  services. Whereas in other countries they do do that.

Sometimes when it is in a public scene or when  there's lots of people around, the paramedics are thinking again about the  safety of everybody else.

And they're also thinking about the dignity of  the person who's died. So, they might actually then consider taking that  patient away from the scene and taking them into the ambulance.

Lauren

When a person dies unexpectedly, different  services, including the ambulance service, will be involved in certifying their  death and notifying the people or organisations that need to be told.

Todd

When somebody dies out of hospital or a  facility, there might be different things that can occur at that point in time.  Generally, the ambulance will arrive because it's related to a medical issue,  or an injury or accident, even when it might be that somebody has clearly died.

In some situations, ambulance paramedics can  declare that person has died. That's all that needs to come to the scene, and  that can occur particularly if the person has a GP that knows that patient had  a medical condition that might have led to the death of that person.

But in some situations, the police might need  to be called as well. There are various situations where they are required to  be called, and it doesn't mean that it's because anyone thinks there's been  something done wrong on scene or somebody's done something illegal. It's really  part of the protocol to really just understand why that person has died.

Usually then they might then be able to  contact family members or contact the person's doctor.

Lauren

Todd told me that as a paramedic, he found the  care he could offer for those present when someone had died was a protective  factor for him as well as for bystanders.

Todd

Even when you would go to a scene and somebody  died, which was really sad, I would have a sense that, ‘Well, I can still  support those people around them.’

You know that there's only so much you can do  for the, patient, but if you can leave the scene and go, ‘But I know that I  could help provide the family with as much information as possible, they knew  what the next steps were and could be as reassured as possible,’ then I think  for paramedics that's equally as satisfying.

Lauren

If you've had an experience where someone  close to you has died unexpectedly, it's normal that hearing the kind of  details we've included in this episode might bring up emotions, memories, or  even physical feelings in your body. If you need some support, we've included  resources in our show notes.

If a person is seriously unwell or injured but  still alive, they will be transported by ambulance to a hospital.

Carly

My name is Carly, and I work in the intensive  care unit at the Townsville University Hospital and I'm the clinical nurse  consultant.

Lauren

Remember Carly from the beginning of the  episode? Sometimes after arriving in an ambulance, a patient might receive  their initial treatment in an emergency department and then get transferred to  a specialised ward. Or they might come straight to the intensive care unit, or  ICU, where they'll be cared for by staff like Carly.

Not all of Carly's patients will come from  outside the hospital. Her team also cares for people who have become very  unwell in hospital or who have had major surgeries and need round-the-clock  care. I asked Carly to explain when a patient might require intensive care.

Carly

Intensive care units provide highly specialised  care for people of all ages who are critically unwell. So, whether that's from  a major trauma, major surgery, severe infection such as sepsis, post cardiac  arrest, stroke, respiratory failure from pneumonia or the flu, they are all  people who might find themselves in an ICU, either expectedly or unexpectedly.

Lauren

Carly explained to me that the reason a person  needs intensive care may determine which health facility they are transferred  to. It's not always just a case of going to the closest hospital. Depending on  where they are in Queensland, they might even be driven or flown to a different  town or city.

Carly

The location and the type of ICU that you end  up in really depends on your reason for needing to be in an ICU, as the  location, depending on where you live, is very specialised for some ICUs.

If you live in, Brisbane that has multiple  ICUs, they tend to be a little bit more specialised and then other ICUs, like  the one that I work at, we do everything. There isn't a patient group that  doesn't come to us if they need an ICU bed.

I think for patients and their families,  sometimes that's challenging because you think, ‘I'll just go to the one that's  closest to home.’

But it doesn't always work out that way,  particularly if you need really specialised care.

Lauren

I've visited ICUs, and they're not like other  hospital wards. From different rules, sounds, and the number of staff, I think  it's helpful to be prepared for the experience.

I asked Carly to explain what her ICU is like  and why it's so different to other areas of the hospital.

Carly

I think it's a really good question, because I  think it's something that ICU clinicians —we lose sight of that because I get up every day and come to work,  and this is my normal. I don't know a different environment. And I think it's  really easy to forget how many Australians have never set foot in an ICU.

They don't know what it looks like. They don't  know what the rules are. I think for many patients and families entering ICU  for the first time, it's a really overwhelming and confronting experience.

ICUs are noisy. They're busy. Everything seems  really invasive. If you're visiting a loved one, they'll likely have lots of  tubes. They'll have lots of devices connected to them. Some of those devices  seem really scary; they're big. They've got lots of numbers, lots of words,  lots of lines. They make lots of noise.

All the beeps sound different. All the alarms  sound different. Everything makes a different noise. Things sound like the  noises are really important, and the nurse or the doctor will just be standing  there having a regular conversation with you, and you'll think, ‘Shouldn't you  be doing something about that noise?’

There's always a lot of staff. It always seems  to be really busy. You'll have one-on-one nursing care, so every patient will  have their own nurse.

If you're a family member, there's a really  good chance that your loved one's not going to look like their usual self,  which can be incredibly confronting for people. Sometimes they might not behave  like themselves. They can be confused and agitated, which can be really  difficult for people to witness when they think, ‘They've never behaved like  this a day in their life.’

So, there's a whole host of things that people  never consider before they step into an ICU.

Lauren

Carly told me that the other thing that often  catches people off guard is that because the care required by patients is so  intensive, visitors can be much more restricted than on a regular ward.

There may only be one person allowed by a  patient's bedside at a time, and they may be asked to leave if the staff need  to do medical procedures or tests.

Carly

The other thing is, and people never realise  this, there's a lot of restrictions in terms of visiting, the number of  visitors you're allowed. There's exclusion time, so if procedures are being  performed or if they're doing medical rounds or if the nurse is doing pressure  area care or something for your loved one, people will ask you to leave all of  the time.

Families often experience a whole host of  emotions. Our goal, I guess, is always to support patients and their families  through it. We have amazing social workers who work very closely with our  families.

And I guess the other thing is, if you're  unsure, you just have to ask, because people will always be happy to answer  your questions, and it's really easy, I guess, for us to forget that you might  not know, because we just do it all the time, so we assume that people  understand when they probably don't.

Lauren

While some patients are admitted to ICU after  a planned surgery and they've been given an idea of what their care and  timeline for being on the ward might look like, for many, an ICU admission  comes out of the blue.

Carly told me that means staff may also not  have the answers about what a patient's trajectory or treatment might be.

Carly

I think the other thing is that sometimes it  does seem like nobody has an answer for why your loved one might be here, or  even an answer for your question, ‘How are we going to treat this? What's the  plan?’

And the reason for that is that truthfully,  sometimes we actually don't know, and we do need a little bit of time to run  all of the tests and start treatment before the exact reason for why they ended  up in the ICU becomes clear.

And I think that can be really frustrating for  people because I think there is an expectation that, well, they're in the ICU  and these people know what they're doing, so they should have an answer for me.  And I think that can be really challenging to have someone say, ‘We're really  not sure. We just need a little bit of time.’

Sometimes we ask you to wait, which waiting's  hard. Waiting's overwhelming.

Lauren

For much of this series, we’ve been talking  about slower declines in health or living with a longer-term diagnosis.

In these situations, time is on your side when  it comes to planning ahead for what medical interventions you'd like to have or  not have, or the situations you'd be okay to find yourself in.

Carly said that even though that's often the  norm, we should still plan ahead with more sudden medical events in mind. Having  had these conversations ahead of time can be really helpful for families or  other loved ones when a person is very unwell in the ICU.

Carly

We give you a lot of information, so much  information in a really short period of time, and then we often ask you to make  decisions really quickly, which can be really, really stressful for people.

One minute you're having a conversation about  why they ended up in ICU, the next minute someone's asking you to sign a  consent form to go to theatre for a procedure, and it all kind of happens very  rapidly. And I think sometimes you don't get a lot of time to process all of  that information and all of those decisions.

So, I think that's why it's really important  to sort of have discussions with your families beforehand about if you ever end  up in those circumstances, what it is that you might or might not want, because  it does help your family to make decisions more rapidly if it's conversations  that you've had before.

Lauren

ICU teams like Carly's spend their days  helping people stay alive and recover from significant illness, injury, or  medical procedures. But even with the best care, not every patient will live. I  asked Carly how they know when a patient might not respond to treatment.

Carly

It's a challenging question to ask because  it's never the same for every patient. There are circumstances where from the  moment they're admitted, we understand that they will not have a favourable  outcome. But then there are other circumstances where it happens over time, or  it's not quite so clear at the beginning.

Identifying that a person is unlikely to  survive despite the intensive treatment that you get in an ICU is a really  considered and ongoing process that involves the ICU team, whatever specialist  teams you might have involved, but then also the multidisciplinary team, you as  a patient, if you're able to participate in your decision-making.

And the way that we sort of come to making  those decisions is the ICU team will continually assess the patient. They'll  assess their response to treatment. They'll see how their underlying illnesses,  so like their pre-existing comorbidities are going. Have we made them worse? Are  they getting better?

And then we'll consider heavily the likelihood  of recovery, meaningful recovery, in terms of you returning to a life that you  would find acceptable.

Lauren

It surprised me to learn that sometimes  patients themselves are part of these conversations. I'd always imagined that  people in ICU are, for the most part, unconscious. But Carly told me that's not  the case.

Carly

Some patients get to participate in this  planning and decision-making. Some people are awake in ICU, and they know that  this is the end of their life. We get to have these discussions. But sometimes  your families have to make those decisions for you.

The goal at the end of life is always to  provide people with the most dignity and comfort as we can for them and their  families.

Lauren

At this point, Carly says that having done  advance care planning and talking about our wishes with our families can be  really impactful, and it's why she encourages us to have these conversations no  matter our stage of life.

Carly

Advanced care planning, for healthcare  professionals, helps us to ensure that the patient's values, their goals, and  their preferences for healthcare and what they would or wouldn't want are  respected and considered, particularly if they find themselves in a situation  where they can't communicate for themselves, which does happen very often in  the ICU.

With that in mind, it's really important to  have had discussions with your family before you ever become unwell so that  it's very clear what your wishes are. Having those conversations, I think, is  the most important part of the process, as I do think it helps your family cope  and process should the time ever come.

I think it makes their decision-making a lot  simpler knowing, ‘Oh, I talked to mum about this, and she said she wouldn't  ever want that.’ Because at the end of the day, we don't want to do anything or  put you through anything that if you had the choice, you wouldn't choose for  yourself.

Once we've considered all of that, if it  becomes clear that treatment is no longer going to achieve meaningful recovery,  or that the person you love won't ever be the person that you know again,  that's kind of when we get to the point where we start talking about  transitioning to comfort-focused care.

Lauren

In the movies, when someone is receiving  intensive care and the decision is made that further treatment isn't their best  option, we're often shown the flicking of a switch, followed by a pretty quick  and sometimes dramatic death. I asked Carly what it's really like when this  decision is made.

Carly

We have access to a whole host of medications  that make them comfortable. Their families get to spend time with them. We do  memory making. We can put on your favourite music. We can do all the things  that you might ever want to do.

We're really lucky; we have an incredible  palliative care centre. We have access to these big, beautiful gardens.

If you decline very rapidly, there might just  come a point where, despite everything that we're doing, your body cannot  sustain what it is doing anymore, and you might die very quickly, which does  happen.

There are some patients, though, where it is a  little bit like the movies, and we do start medications to keep them  comfortable, and then we will, sort of, take the breathing tube out and turn  the ventilator off. And generally, people will pass quite peacefully and quite  quickly.

I think people get really scared that they're going  to suffer. But I can tell you that it is an ICU clinician's worst nightmare to  have anybody suffer. So, it is not something that we do. We make people the  most comfortable that we can.

There's this really interesting concept  amongst healthcare professionals when you've done it for a really long time,  where you realise that there are choices that are worse than dying. And  sometimes we do see that with people, and I certainly know that it's not  something I would ever choose for my family or my loved ones. I would want them  to be comfortable and dignified, and I would want to be able to spend time with  them.

So, for the most part, it's not like Grey's  Anatomy, but there are different circumstances for every situation, and I  think that's the really hard part about ICU, is it's never the same. But the  end result is always the same, and that is that people are comfortable and they  don't suffer.

Meagan

Sometimes we have family that raise donation  spontaneously, they know loved one's wishes and are advocating for their loved  one to be an organ donor. Other circumstances where we raise donation, it can  be a bit of a shock to the family.

Lauren

To finish off this episode, I spoke to Carly's  colleague Megan about organ donation.

Meagan

My name is Megan. I'm an ICU nurse at  Townsville University Hospital and I'm also a donation nurse specialist, for  DonateLife.

Lauren

Many people don't know that to be an organ  donor, you need to die while ventilated, which means most donors are receiving  ICU care when the conversation about donation begins.

Meagan

The opportunity for someone to donate their  organs is quite rare. Not everyone can donate their organs because to donate  your organs, the person requires to die in a specific hospital setting, usually  on a ventilator in the intensive care unit. That's so that the organs remain  functional and healthy up until the time of donation surgery.

Only about 2% of the way people die in  Australia in a position where they can help others through organ donation. Generally,  the conditions that people have to contribute to them being an organ donor are,  where the person has sustained a severe brain injury, and often they progress  to something we call brain death, and that's the irreversible cessation of the  function of the whole brain.

Lauren

For many families and friends of organ donors,  Megan says the donation process gives them a positive out of what was often a  very dark time.

Meagan

When we raise organ donation, we try to give  them enough information to ensure that the decision they're making is a  decision that they're comfortable with, not only on that day, but in the weeks,  months, and years going forward.

And we know like for some families, organ  donation is the only thing they've seen positive through that admission, that  every other aspect has been a shock. Nothing has been a pleasant experience but  knowing that their loved one is able to help others through organ donation is  the only thing that they see as a positive aspect.

Lauren

Our next episode is going to be all about  organ and tissue donation. So, if you're after more information, including who  can register as a donor and what the process is like for donors and recipients,  make sure you tune in.

Many of us won't ever experience what it's  like to become or care for someone who becomes unexpectedly ill or dies  suddenly. But most of us will know someone it's happened to and will find  ourselves searching for understanding about their experience.

All of us can take time to think about what  our wishes would be if we ended up being treated by paramedics like Todd's team  or in an ICU with staff like Carly or Meagan, and we can talk to those who care  about us and who we care about, to understand their wishes and share our own.

In our next episode, we're going to be  learning more about organ and tissue donation. We'll hear from the DonateLife  team about how organ and tissue donation work, how to register as a potential  donor in Australia, and why it's so important to share our preferences with  those close family or loved ones who may consent on our behalf.

We'll also hear from Rob and his wife Janet,  who received a liver from an organ donor just this year.

Janet

All I could think of is, "What's he doing  on the phone at this time of night?" Like, "Well, get off the  phone." And then he just turned to me while he was still talking to the  surgeon, and just thumbs up, and I started to cry, and then he had a tear.

Lauren

And Helen, who tells us about the experience  of being given the gift of renewed sight from a tissue donor.

Helen

So I did that, went back to sit at my desk in  front of the computer, and it was the first time in my life that I realised  that a keyboard, the keys on a keyboard actually had depth. Prior to that it  was flat.

Lauren

How do you register as an organ and tissue  donor? Can you pick what parts of your body you'd be comfortable to donate? Why  is it so hard to find donor and recipient matches? It can't hurt to ask!

​